Where Shall We Meet
Explorations of topics about society, culture, arts, technology and science with your hosts Natascha McElhone and Omid Ashtari.
The spirit of this podcast is to interview people from all walks of life on different subjects. Our hope is to talk about ideas, divorced from our identities - listening, learning and maybe meeting somewhere in the middle. The perfect audio diet for shallow polymaths!
Natascha McElhone is an actor and producer.
Omid Ashtari is a tech entrepreneur and angel investor.
Where Shall We Meet
On Facts with Alessandra Galloni
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Questions, suggestions, or feedback? Send us a message!
Welcome to the Where Shall We Meet podcast. Our guest this week is Alessandra Galloni, Editor-in-Chief of Reuters. She took the job in 2021, the first woman to lead the agency in its 175-year history. Her five years in charge have run from the evacuation of Kabul through the war in Ukraine, Gaza and now Iran. Her view of the job is that "there cannot be any moral clarity without the facts."
Reuters is a foundation of the news ecosystem. It has 2,600 journalists of more than 100 nationalities, working in around 200 locations and publishing in 16 languages. It serves financial markets and more than a thousand media organisations, and increasingly readers directly. The newsroom still works by the Trust Principles, which were drawn up during the Second World War to guard against propaganda from the British government. This year Reuters won two Pulitzer Prizes, one of them for its investigations into harm on Meta's platforms.
Alessandra was born in Rome. She studied government at Harvard and took a master's at the LSE. She joined Reuters in 1996 on its Italian-language service, then spent thirteen years at The Wall Street Journal as a correspondent in London, Paris and Rome and as its Southern Europe bureau chief. She went back to Reuters in 2013 and became global managing editor. She also co-wrote Pope Francis: From the End of the Earth to Rome.
We talk about:
- The robust process of getting to the truth
- Reuters' Palestinian journalists in Gaza, and vitriol from both sides
- Does covering Trump this much just amplify him?
- The Tesla stories nobody asked her to drop
- Can there be moral clarity without facts?
- Show me the incentives and I'll show you the outcome
- Are AI models the audience of the future?
- There are no shortcuts to wisdom
Let's begin!
Web: www.whereshallwemeet.xyz
Twitter: @whrshallwemeet
Instagram: @whrshallwemeet
Welcome And Why Facts Matter
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Where Shall We Meet podcast. Our guest this week is Alessandra Galoni, editor-in-chief of Reuters. She took the job in 2021, the first woman to lead the agency in its 175 year history. Her five years in charge have run from the evacuation of Kabul through to the war in Ukraine, Gaza, and now Iran. Her view of the job is that there cannot be any more clarity without the facts.
SPEAKER_01Reuters is a foundation of the news ecosystem. It has 2,600 journalists of more than 100 nationalities, working in around 200 locations and publishing in 16 languages. It serves financial markets and more than a thousand media organizations, and increasingly readers directly. The newsroom still works by the trust principles, which were drawn up during the Second World War to guard against propaganda from the British government. This year Reuters won two Pulitzer Prizes, one of them for its investigations into harm on Meta's platforms.
SPEAKER_00Alessandra was born in Rome. She studied government at Harvard and took a master's at the LSE. She joined Reuters in 1996 on its Italian language service, then spent 13 years at the Wall Street Journal as a correspondent in London, Paris, Rome, and as its Southern European Bureau Chief. She went back to Reuters in 2013 and became global managing editor. She also co-wrote Pope Francis From the End of the Earth to Rome.
SPEAKER_01We talk about the robust process of getting to the truth.
SPEAKER_00Reuters Palestinian journalists in Gaza and the vitriol from both sides.
SPEAKER_01Does covering Trump this much just amplify him?
SPEAKER_00The Tesla stories nobody asked her to drop.
SPEAKER_01Can there be moral clarity without facts?
SPEAKER_00Show me the incentives, and I'll show you the outcome.
SPEAKER_01Are AI models the audience of the future?
SPEAKER_00There are no shortcuts to wisdom.
SPEAKER_01Let's begin.
SPEAKER_00Hi, this is Amida Schnari.
SPEAKER_01And Natasha McElhone. And with us today we have
SPEAKER_02Alessandra Galoni.
SPEAKER_00Hey Alessandra.
SPEAKER_01So nice to have you here. Thank you.
SPEAKER_02Thank you.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for taking the time. We will speak about facts today. And as such, we figured we start by asking you about the manufacturing of the facts
What Makes A Fact Publishable
SPEAKER_00that you're putting out. What actually has to be true for something to qualify to go out on the wire?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So thank you so much for having me. Yes, facts. We care deeply at Reuters about facts. And it takes a lot of work to certify that something is a fact and put it out into the world. Now, of course, it depends what you're covering, right? You know, sometimes if there is a fact, uh a piece of information from a verified source that we feel is important for, say, a financial audience, because we have many financial customers, then we will sort of put the Reuters in primature and put it out there. If we feel pretty confident, you know, if a company is reporting its results or something like that. You know. So that's, you know, I would say quite easy, although sometimes you see there can be problems with that too. The harder facts, of course, are those in situations that are highly controversial. Uh so, you know, since I've been EIC, I've been in this job for five years, we've had many conflicts. We've, of course, had Ukraine. Well, we started with the evacuation of Kabul, so we had Afghanistan, we had Ukraine, we've had Gaza, now we have Iran. And in all of these conflicts, there has been an attempt by generally by both sides in in each uh conflict to spread misinformation, propaganda, and facts that simply were not verified. But by the time news organizations like ours verified them, the damage had been done. And that's part of the difficulty that we face today.
SPEAKER_01It was ever thus, no, was it was it church? I can't remember. It's probably been misattributed, you know, by the time lies traveled around the world, the truth hasn't got its shoes on or some version of it, something like that. Yeah. Um that that's not new.
SPEAKER_02It's not new. It's not new. And in fact, something that struck me is um in we were thinking about this and and we invited into the newsroom a psychologist who worked on the who works on the effect of misinformation on people. And he told us, he said, that the damage, the danger with misinformation is that you have a fact that you believe and then it's debunked, and you may rationally believe that, okay, it's not true. I thought it was true, it's not true, but the emotion it elicited in you remains. And that's in part why uh mistruths sort of linger out there, you know, it's like once once they're out there. But yes, it it has existed for a long time. So at Reuters, we have what we call the trust principles. And these are five commandments, if you will, that dictate that we always have to give reliable and independent news to all of our clients, our clients being, as I said before, the financial markets, our clients being all the news organizations in the world, and increasingly a direct audience through our website. And we sort of live according to these five uh trust principles. They were created during World War II precisely because there was a danger of propaganda by the British government. And so it existed already, right? And journalists had to be careful, and that's why this news organization created the trust principles to protect exactly from the same sort of things that we see now. So you're totally right. It it is not a new situation, yeah.
SPEAKER_00It's the same same thing in a different suit, I guess. Um with a different
SPEAKER_02But the the difference is the pace.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So the fact that governments will try to spread misinformation is not new. But now, of course, technological tools allows it to go much faster. And and again, and they are so sophisticated. We, like other news organizations, have a sort of blossoming fact-checking operation. And, you know, what you see increasingly, it is so good. I mean, we we often do little internal seminars, you know, with the newsroom where the fact-checking operation sort of gives us these uh videos and uh photos and asks everybody, okay, which ones are and I mean it's impossible. I mean, it is virtually impossible. And and interestingly, the way we verify uh content, for example, user-generated content that comes to us from people in the field, um, because of course we have our own journalists, 160 countries, 200 locations, but obviously we can't be everywhere. So we rely increasingly on user-generated content. And the way we fact check it is yes, with technological tools, but also with the old rules of shoe leather reporting. So if we have a video from somewhere of a, you know, an explosion in a, I don't know, oil plant or something, we will try to call people who would have been there and say, Did you see the same thing that this
Fighting Propaganda With Verification
SPEAKER_02video shows? So kind of the old fashioned call up people and and stress test it on the ground because the stuff that comes in
SPEAKER_01is
SPEAKER_02crazy but hard to verify.
SPEAKER_01I'm I'm so happy you've raised that because one of the things I wanted to ask you about was listening to a journalist from Al Jazeera. I wasn't familiar with power until I started listening to this podcast, Dima Khatib. Do you do you know her?
SPEAKER_02Um
SPEAKER_01one of the things that she was saying was there's been a proliferation of uh the these kind of dirty tricks, if you like, on one side um that haven't been verified. So someone pretending to be a Palestinian and saying certain things that there was no factual basis for, and then a Western news platform picking that up, not checking properly. Um I'm sure it's very hard to check, of course, because if you haven't got any journalists on the ground, as is the case I think in Gaza Right for the last couple of years. Or
SPEAKER_02so some did, some news organizations did, but nobody was able to go in or out. So it was the ones who were there already.
SPEAKER_01Already. Yeah. Yeah. Um and the complaint was that uh no one seems to care about whether these things are actually true or not. How do you as an organization I mean you've just said that you do check with people on the ground w when you've seen photos or videos of something that could be AI generated or could be out of context. And that's a whole new world, presumably.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it is. I mean,
Gaza Reporting And Trust Under Fire
SPEAKER_02so for us specifically in Gaza, uh, we had uh 10 journalists on the ground. And these are Reuters journalists who have been there for years. We've been there for decades. And we did, uh I would say that Associated Press did, AFP did, the BBC did. We were the four news organizations that had a had bureaus. I mean, we had offices there, and Al Jazeera, of course. And so we had our own journalists who for years had worked within Reuters, so know how to report, know how to send their stories, whether it be visual or text stories, through an editing system. It goes through the the Reuters system, if you will, make sure that it's balanced. So anything that came out that was declared within Gaza, we would of course, you know, check if you had something about a an explosion in a hospital, and there were the Palestinian health authorities would say there were X number of people killed. We would also see what from the Israeli side, from the IDF side, you know, what did you see? What was your target? So we would try as much as possible to make it balanced, at the very least, to have comment from the other side. We always try to do this. In Gaza, when you had irrefutable evidence, such as our journalists there on the ground, walking amid the debris and counting the bodies, that is irrefutable evidence, right? And that is what we were able to do because we had people in the ground. And that is a responsibility. It was also an incredible, um, I mean, it was a blessing, right? Because we felt that we could say, this is what is happening. We are seeing it with our own eyes and ears. Now, what was the problem in Gaza was that most of the journalists, in fact, all of the journalists who were there for these four news organizations, and there were some others, I think some of the American networks had a couple of people who they then evacuated at the beginning, was that they're all Palestinian. And so immediately what happened is that there were doubts over whether they were telling the true story because what was said by many was that they had a bias, right? And what we argued is these are, yes, the their nationality, they are Palestinian, but they are Reuters journalists. And not only, they're there, they're witnessing, and their material goes through the Reuters editing process just like anything else, from Ukraine, from Sudan, from now from Iran or from wherever, goes through the editing process. So we felt that our coverage was factual, was factual about what was going on on the ground. Now, one can like it or not like what they see, and most people did not like what they saw.
SPEAKER_01So how do you cope with the response to the truth that you're seeing and the, I guess, interested parties who I d I'm I don't know what the background of the financial structure of Reuters is and what the vested interests are, because there are just are with every company, and there's obviously a very big presence in America and so forth. If you are reporting something that is deeply unpopular and doesn't fit with the narrative of the government, and well, what do you do in that situation? How do you navigate that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean it's obviously a big question and it depends, but I think a few things. First of all, we are lucky in that people don't know what nationality we are. So we are actually Canadian. Um, but we've gone through many different ownership structures by parents. So we started out as German um because Julius, the Baron Julius Reuters was German. Then we became English. Uh, and then over the takeover of Thomson of Reuters by Thompson of Reuters, we became Canadian. And in a way, the fact that that nobody quite knows that. Um, I mean, I'm sure David Thompson, our boss, he would like it, he talks about it and we're very proud of it. But I mean, you know, the the fact that just are you German? Are you this? Are you are you what are you, right? That kind of helps us. But it's
SPEAKER_01still Western.
SPEAKER_02It's still Western. It is still Western. But, and I think this is a crucial difference. We have 2,600 journalists around the world, and we employ all nationalities. So we employ uh our journalists uh are from, you know, a hundred more than a hundred nationalities, and we, you know, speak, you know, I think in our we publish in 16 languages, but the languages spoken are are, you know, many more. And crucially, we have a mix of foreign correspondents and local correspondents. So we have a mix of people who fly in, whether they're they can be from anywhere, they fly in as as international correspondents, but they they work always with people who are covering their own countries. And that's a way that we create balance. So one way we create balance is through the editing process. But the other way is to balance the
SPEAKER_01whatever, the local
SPEAKER_02knowledge, you
SPEAKER_01know,
SPEAKER_02local person who it can be deep and that's important. It can also not know the view of the world. And so the international correspondent balances that. So the criticism in Gaza was that because nobody could go in and nobody could go out, is that you only had Palestinian correspondence and you couldn't have, you know, with the Christian Amanpours of the world. And she was very understandably rightly was very vocal about, well, why aren't you letting journalists in? Does it, you know, and to Israel saying, do you have something to hide? Otherwise, why would you not let journalists in? And that's a legitimate, that's a legitimate question, right? But we felt that because our journalists were Reuters, um, you know, that that that we felt we like like BBC, like AFP, like AP, we really felt that we were representing uh the truth on the ground. Now, we got it from both sides. I mean, the letters that I got, the vitriol that I got from both sides was like never from nothing I'd ever seen before, all the way from sort of U.S. senators to um, you know, to people, you know, across the Middle East. And so in a way, I mean, not that I like, you know, receiving criticism and I want to be careful to say, well, if everybody hates you, then it's okay. Because that that that's not also I'm not saying that, but to a certain extent, the fact that people felt that on one day we were biased towards one side and on the other day we were biased towards the other side, even though we felt that we were straight down the middle. In a sense, that did indicate to us that while doing the right
SPEAKER_00job.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that we're not perfect, right? There were mistakes made, right? There were mistakes made. And I think in the beginning, you know, we took as gospel certain things that were said to us, um, and you know, we learned as we went along. Also, a lot of journalists went in as embeds. And the whole concept of embeds is a very tricky one. But that's
SPEAKER_01another one that I in fact she um uh Dima was talking about extensively is how can you possibly have impartiality if you're going in and being protected by the British um uh army or or the American. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I don't like there's an obligation there to
SPEAKER_00I think what I'm hearing is this is a thoughtful organization that is trying to check itself and creating checks and balances on itself to make sure that there is a process to generate facts. Now, I think the Gaza Israel situation is obviously a very tricky one, but I'm sure there's situations where you give facts to organizations that fabricate their own truth.
SPEAKER_02So what
SPEAKER_00is what is the distance between the fact and the truth? You're essentially providing ammunition to the people who are misleading as well. I mean, this is the reality of what's part of your job, right?
SPEAKER_02And that happens, right? I mean, we have um more than a thousand clients in the media companies that subscribe to us. And it does happen where you will give an objective fact and in the way that that is positioned, in the way that that that is twisted or cushioned or you know, and and then suddenly it's Reuters reports, you know. And we try to be very careful when that happens to say, no, that's actually not what we what we reported. Um sometimes we succeed, sometimes we don't. And I but I think that, you know, and if it's egregious, we really go, we really go after them and we say no, no, no, then we put out a statement. Um, but generally we try to let our facts sort of stand for themselves as much as we can. You know, sometimes things are so egregious that you have to sort of stand up and say, hey, hang on a second, right?
SPEAKER_00Another point I would want to kind of go a little bit more upstream,
Who Decides What Gets Covered
SPEAKER_00Natasha pointed out, is obviously commercial organization. You said that you're Canadian. And I guess if you're reporting facts, by definition, you have limited attention, even though you have thousands of journalists, where you're pointing your attention is an editorial decision.
SPEAKER_01It's already a filter. How
SPEAKER_00do you feel about that? How do you go about that? How do you try to be balanced in that regard?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. You know, where you put more people on the ground, you know, now it's no secret that we, like other news organizations, are covering the Trump administration a lot. And some of the criticism, and let's be honest, is well, you know, if you're covering it so much, then you're amplifying some of the work. And that's a legitimate criticism. My response would be what the U.S. administration does matters in the world, as we are seeing, and it has a trickle effect on other countries. And also, we did not expect this administration to work so much on foreign affairs. This was an administration that we thought, you know, was there, right, to make America great again internally. And instead, oh, we've had Iran, we've had Venezuela, we've had we'll see what happens in Cuba, we've had Greenland, right?
SPEAKER_01As we know, this leader is very performative. Um, and he's very interested in attention. And you may not get nearly as much attention for internal politics then as you would in international politics and invading countries. And he's just getting all the attention he could ever have wished for, and you know, 10x. I I do sometimes wonder if some of his or the administration's response to all of this attention is just to keep the ball in the air.
SPEAKER_02Possibly. I mean, possibly. Uh
SPEAKER_01it would just be an interesting thought experiment if you withdrew, if no one mentioned or no one had a photograph of him. Professor.
SPEAKER_00So it's interesting,
SPEAKER_02but we almost have that counterfactual and and which I'll come to in a second. I mean, one thing that we try to do is, and again, we're fortunate because we have so many people, is we have huge bureaus in China. We have huge offices in the Middle East, we're one of the biggest news organizations in the Middle East. We have hundreds of people in India. So everything that is said, particularly on international affairs, we show the other side. Um, and you know, the effects of the trade war, we were able to measure it, for example, just as one example, we were able to measure it on the ground in many, many dozens of countries, right? So that's a way that we stress test. But well, there were two other one was on the the ownership, right? Because that's another way to impose um and on news organizations and to restrict freedom of the press. Uh
SPEAKER_01to choose where you shine the light. Or to choose,
SPEAKER_02right? So I I always say knock on wood because you never know how things happen. I mean, I feel we feel very lucky with our ownership. So our parent company, Thomson Reuters, has contracts with the U.S. government. Not for our news, we're a small part of the Thomson Reuters, but because they provide services to the U.S. government. Thomson Reuters has legal services, tax and accounting services, um, and and is in many other businesses. And there have been threats on Thomson Reuters, and contracts have been canceled on Thomson Reuters because of coverage that we have done, in particular on the Trump administration and in particular on Elon Musk. And I am happy to say, and and again, I always I really count my blessings, and I feel so privileged and lucky to say that never once, and it's cost them a lot of money, never once has TR, the CEO, the owner, you know, come to us and said, Hey, you know, do you really need to do the lay another Tesla story? Do you really need to do a SpaceX? You know, so but to your point about what if we all left? So interestingly, the Trump administration tried to play this, right? When they kicked out the AP from the White House,
SPEAKER_00right?
SPEAKER_02When they made, they put such stringent rules on the Pentagon, thinking that, oh yes, because we think it's so important to be in the Pentagon that we will all sort of sign on, essentially giving away all that, right? And guess what? Everybody left. And so we'll see how that works out, because all of us are still doing defense and Pentagon stories, you know, all of us. It hasn't actually changed the amount of coverage that has been been done on these issues. On the White House, the agencies used to have privileged access to the White House. And then the the administration, and it's their prerogative. I will say that it's their prerogative. An administration comes on and says, these are the people I want in my press conference, so be it. I mean, this happens in many other countries, and we don't even question it in many other countries. It's just that in the US, it's sort of American exceptionalism where obviously freedom of the press is protected and is so important that we were all shot. But anyway, so we no longer got privileged access. Um, the news agencies and access, it was essentially going to be shared. With everybody, which meant that Reuters had the same access as like a right way, you know, a MAGA podcaster. Again, their prerogative. But over time, what happened is that you need tools, you need money to go in places like to set up equipment in the White House, to go on Air Force One. Going on Air Force or Air Force One costs money. So slowly, one by one, you know, all of the news organizations sort of dropped out. And at the end of the day, we we still were able to report. Now I will say that's access journalism. It's important to be in the room and understand and you know talk to the people in the room. But actually, when you're kicked out, you probably do better journalism because you go and find sources and you go and actually report it out.
SPEAKER_01So
SPEAKER_02bottom line is this attempt to kind of crimp um press access hasn't quite I mean, don't get me wrong, it is bad. Okay. It is bad and criminalization of our work is really bad. But we have found ways around it and we've still been able to do coverage. Whether it's too much is a legitimate question. And our answer to it would be it is important because what this administration does matters to people's lives. But what
Moral Clarity Requires Verified Facts
SPEAKER_02we try to do is we balance it out with the other side.
SPEAKER_00Speaking of uh, I guess this notion of balance, truth, perspective, I heard you have this conversation around, and we spoke a lot about being down the middle, objectivity, about this argument that some journalists point that they put first is moral clarity over objectivity. And I would like you, I know that you're on the objectivity side given your profession, but can you steel man the other side? Can you steel man the moral clarity argument?
SPEAKER_02I I mean, look, I think as a human being, I often say, yes, I'm a journalist, but I'm also a human, you know, as a human being, as a mother, you know, I I want people to to know that there are certain things that are right and there are certain things that are wrong, right? And I understand. And I love the fact that especially this younger generation feels very strongly about being advocates and fighting for what is right. I feel that that's more than when I was growing up, and that is great. Um, and also I believe in freedom of speech, of course, right? But I guess my argument for us, for Reuters, which is a news agency, which is at the at the foundation of the news ecosystem, I would say there cannot be any moral clarity without the facts. We will provide the facts and you all do what you think is right. But you can't do it unless you know the fact is the foundation of this. And and that's what our role is. I will just say one other thing, which is taking it down the middle as we do and giving the facts does not mean not having a point of view when all the facts point to that. So if you are, as we've done, you know, done many investigations say about harm done, for example, by uh in some cases Meta. Um, I mean, in it's an investigation that we just won the Pulitzer for just a few weeks ago. That's that you could argue that has a point of view, but the facts pointed to a conclusion that we could verifiably make, and also that we fairly made, taking into account Meta's point of view. This was a series that we did on how essentially on Facebook some people would get led to harm, you know, through a a combination of sort of allowing certain types of advertising or certain types of content to be on that would then harm or ruin the life of people. Somebody could say, oh, well, you took a point of view, you took aim. And it's like, no, this is an important societal issue. People are being hurt. It is our role to understand why people are being hurt, and the facts lead to a point. So those two things can coexist, right? One of the things that I don't like is on the one hand, on the overhand, on the other hand, on the on the other hand, right, that actually doesn't help the consumer, the reader, right? You have to you build up facts. Well, you start with a hypothesis, and you have to be ready as a journalist for that hypothesis to be completely wrong. And and that happens often. But if the facts lead to confirming that hypothesis or in another path to confirming another set of facts, then those facts put together can provide a a a new reality, again, a point of view,
SPEAKER_00um,
SPEAKER_02but that is sort of forged in the crucible of fact, if you will.
SPEAKER_01I don't know the answer to this, which is why I'm throwing it out, because I find it really confounding. Just on the Israel-Palestinian situation, and it's not something I talk about very often with people, which is why I was so uh uh behind, I think, in a really great discussion I had with a friend the other night, who had a very specific point of view and a belief system based on a lot of facts or what he believed what where he'd sourced his facts from, that they were true, they were verifiable. And I I must have had, even though we're very aligned morally, I thought, ethically, you know, on all sorts of fronts, I had a different set of sources. And I believe that uh the crisis had very much been seen from the Palestinian point of view, that there'd been an awful lot of media um and a lot of sympathy and and a lot of money raised and um a lot of support. And yes, governments are behaving Western governments are for sure supporting Israel, but people, citizens, are not. But you know, to his point, well, if those marches aren't being covered properly in the media um and the media isn't covering the citizens' outrage at this genocide, where where is the journalism? You know, you're omitting, even though the stories that are being reported might be fact-based, if you're not reporting uh the the real sentiment and you're missing out on that, and and you know, to his we cons was consuming different media because I thought it was being well represented. And he pointed out quite rightly, and that's why I did my deep dive into Al Jazeera and listening to Palestinian podcasts. You know, I listened to a whole plethora of things. I'm very familiar with Sam Harris's stance on this subject, which is one end of the spectrum. Um I'm also, you know, a guardian reader of Atlantic, whatever, lots of different things, but I was not getting the perspective that he was getting. And it was by omission, it's not that I'd been reading false media necessarily. There was just so many facts that I I had not been consuming, which would have totally changed my point of view about an awful lot of
SPEAKER_02it. Yeah, I mean, I think this speaks to two things. Um, one is it's very easy in the media landscape, in the media and the social media and the AI landscape of today, to go down the path that you already where you had that hypothesis and that that just sort of is so easy to do that, right? It's much easier to do that than somehow to sort of balance, you know. You can do it without knowing. That's
SPEAKER_01my point.
SPEAKER_02Without knowing it, right? Um because I mean, as we all know, you get the people suggest things and and you say, oh, this is interesting. Let me click on this, and you can go deeper and deeper and deeper. And and the the other problem, I think, is that I'm obviously oh I don't particularly like this name, but I'm legacy media, right? I'm legacy media, and so um we do things sort of a way, really at Reuters, we're 175 years old, and our principles have not changed that much in 175 years. Our formats and the way we do things are different, but really our fundamental principles of news gathering are are no different. But we are lucky, insofar as we are a big legacy media, to have people in both sides so that we can cover both, you know, the pro the pro-Palestinian protest in London or wherever it is. We can also cover very deeply the huge rise in anti-Semitism in the UK and and elsewhere. And we have people, we have a huge bureau on the ground in Jerusalem, in Tel Aviv, just like we had until we eventually evacuated them because obviously they were exhausted and working under bombs. But we had a big bureau in in Gaza as well. And so, but not a lot of the social media or even the smaller, more advocacy news organizations that are out there, they don't have the means to stress test and to balance, right? To through no fault of their own. I mean, it it it it's just and also they're advocates. Um it's very easy just to go to go down that that path. We would love people to sort of come straight to us and to our platforms, right? Um it becomes easier now with the AI and with the LLMs that have done deals with a lot of news organizations, including ours. We want to be sourced for that because we want people, if if you do a search and whatever AI gives you suggests at this point, we want them to say, click on this, which is Reuters, right? And that's our big gripe with them is fine. We've all done deals with you, you train on us, but you've got to give us for intellectual property, you've got to give us attribution so that if people want to know more, they go to a
SPEAKER_01social
SPEAKER_02not, you know, not to others. Um and I think then what happens is as you go down in that path, then you become more entrenched. Rather than becoming more open, I mean, I'm not saying you, but I mean in general, that this is what can happen, right? I mean, let's face it, you add on top of that, Israel Gaza really was about one of the most vicious cultural, religious, political conflicts of our age of of many ages, right? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And it's it's at this point, it's also good business to feed the beast. So it's a continuing perpetual cycle of bifurcation, right? So uh and I'm not suggesting you guys are doing that, but I'm just saying in general, uh, if you if your model's advertising, right, you basically want to get the clicks, and to get the clicks, you want to feed the people who are in one side of the camp exactly what they want to hear. And people want to hear what feels good.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, I think the problem that I have, I mean, in general, I think that conflict is very clear to me. This is one oppressor, there's one one side that is trying to defend. Obviously, it's not as clean as I just made it out to be, but like I don't think there's a lot more to say on that. Of course, we can put our attention to it, but I want to go back to my original question on this, is like there is also a conflict in Sudan, right? And I don't want to take away at all from this conflict, but the reality is we
SPEAKER_01No one cares.
SPEAKER_00Nobody cares. Attention is so bifurcated. And so when you are so obsessed with that one conflict, yeah, and it becomes everything for
SPEAKER_01you,
SPEAKER_00and everything is just about that one thing, you're you're really kind of confused about the state of the world in some ways. And I'm not suggesting that you should not be passionate about it if if you believe in that cause and you know it is horrendous what is happening. But um we are making a moral decision there as well. And it seems to feel so good. You
SPEAKER_01mean by ignoring all of these?
SPEAKER_00And so it is it feels really good to care about one thing. And I mean we have to direct our attention, we have limited attention, we have to direct it somewhere where we care. But we should be careful to suggest that everybody should care as much as we should about this one thing. Because it is by virtue of everybody caring about the things that they care about that we reveal a lot more truth and a lot more issues on this planet.
SPEAKER_01Well, you made a point earlier on about not ambivalence, but overunderstanding of both sides of a conflict can lead to um a certain kind of apathy and lack of action. And in fact, you know, to use the example that I said with this dear friend of mine having this conversation, his very passion and tenacity around what he had heard and experienced and what more to the point, what he'd seen ignored that had aggravated him so much and aggravated him, I mean I mean, he was irritated with me because I wasn't giving attention to the things that I should be giving it to, largely because there were areas of coverage that I simply wasn't aware of. Um and I'm so grateful for that passion and single-mindedness and tenacity and bravery to say, What are you thinking? Even why are you putting your attention there? It should be here. And you know, because I respect him and I I I went off and I did some due diligence. Um and I think we need people to be obsessed with one thing, journalists to be obsessed and specialists in one area. And then we need you as as the arbiter of this information war essentially to say, but this is also important, and we need to highlight this and this and this. I don't think one person within themselves can highlight both arguments as effectively as someone who is completely convinced that they're right about something. I think there's something very useful about that for us not all to be incredibly measured in our approach.
SPEAKER_00100%. The problem that I was trying to highlight is that there seems to be an obligation by people who are very passionate about any subject uh that is politically freighted, more morally freighted thereby to be myopically focused on their topic. And uh I am accused very often to not point my attention to the things that some people want me to point my attention to. And I'd rather point my attention to a lot of things. And I think it's great that some people point their attention to something, but I was telling you this, I was on a dating app today and and somebody had like a voice prompt, and on that voice prompt said, if you don't care about XYZ, I don't I think you're uh a monster. Right? So uh this this type of thing is now. She's being very clear
SPEAKER_01and declarative. No, no, no.
SPEAKER_00It's great. It's great, but
SPEAKER_01I
SPEAKER_00don't mind. What I'm just saying is uh I I find that that's the problem. And uh by the way, I also think that's what got Donald Trump elected to an extent. This uh notion that you speak from a moral high ground to people below you and say, I care about something, you don't care about this, you're worse than me, therefore I somehow am virtue signaling here, etc. I think that it's
SPEAKER_01a lot of people.
SPEAKER_00What's so
SPEAKER_01extraordinary about that particular scenario is this is someone who has very, very few facts at his fingertips. I mean, the two th the conflict, he says it's a 3,000-year-old conflict or something. The state of Israel like 47, was it? Um 1947. I mean, it's just extraordinary how no one even calls him on this shit. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But anyway, sorry, I'm gonna go down that way.
SPEAKER_02But on your dating app, not that we need to, you know, this is a family podcast analyzer, but on your on your, you know, the the fact of the matter is you don't want someone like that because actually the best thing and the most courageous thing that people can do, like you did with your friend, is actually seek out people who have a different point of view than than than you do. I mean, on Sudan,
Attention Economy And News Business Models
SPEAKER_02I couldn't agree with you more. I will say that we have been in Sudan for years, and we have run reporting on Sudan for years. And here is where the commercial side does make a difference because we're we are mainly a B2B business, so we provide our news to other businesses, whether those be financial or news organizations, we have a financial model that protects us. We can do Sudan because we don't have to worry that no one will click on Sudan right now. Also, we now have a website and we're charging for it a pound a week, a dollar a week, or you know, worth every penny. And uh, you know, but
SPEAKER_01you have a podcast as well,
SPEAKER_02and we have podcasts, yeah. You know, again, newsletters. Um so we're entering sort of the consumer world, but it's a small part of that which makes our money. And so the having a stable commercial backing, and there are news organizations that that have that, gives you the courage and the ability to do things even though that nobody clicks on them. And and that unfortunately, that's why the financial state of journalism is so important. You know, that's why we have to bang on about intellectual property. You know, that's why we have to make sure that that news organizations are solvent, because otherwise you will only go down either paths where people feel super passionate because it's a conflict that has been going on because it is a money issue. You know, I hate to say things are a money issue, but actually, and also it costs money to do this work. I mean, I can't even tell you the insurance that it that it costs us for every person we have in Ukraine who goes to the front line regularly. We have two armored vehicles in Ukraine. Those cost a hell of a lot of money. In Gaza, as we were saying before, nobody could go in and nobody could go out of foreign press. One thing we haven't said here, more than one thing can be true, and that's where you look at the picture. October 7th was one of the most horrific acts of brutality and violence and just degradation. And I can't even find the words to say that, right? We all know that, right? The reaction, I think everybody would agree, was disproportionate, vastly horrifically disproportionate. For us, it was also for us as journalists, it was also disproportionate. More journalists were killed in Gaza than all other conflicts put together. I mean, it was. And there was, there's been this whole debate over whether, you know, the journalists were, they were going after journalists or it was just part of, you know, mistakes of civilians. Well, when so many are killed, there that that suggests a targeting. We fell into that. One of our journalists was killed in Gaza, and another one of our journalists was killed by Israeli fire in Lebanon. And I have asked, I personally have asked, we as a news organization, and I personally have asked for explanation and accountability, and I've received none. And that also is a fact, right? So again, then everybody can piece together, you know, and you and your friend had a had a robust debate, but all of these things are are are true. And then one can have right or can be true at the same at the same time. And
SPEAKER_00anti-Semitism is on the rise, which is also true. And as we said, anti-
SPEAKER_02anti-Semitism is is is on the rise, you know. Um Well,
SPEAKER_01the um the other thing, I don't even know if we have time to go into this, but is the conflation, the the the headline, just this idea that um because you're Jewish, you are
SPEAKER_00I mean, this is
SPEAKER_01fading now because uh fortunately there has been some c good coverage uh about trying to explain that that is just not the case. That's someone who's
SPEAKER_02yeah, yeah. Oh that well, I mean that's ignorance. That's just plain ignorance, right? And also, I mean But how do
SPEAKER_01we deal with ignorance? I mean, that's again your your job, right? I mean
SPEAKER_02and people too well, so yes, it's our job, but as I think we were saying before, perhaps off mic, you know. But
SPEAKER_01about Sudan. Um,
SPEAKER_02we're gonna be aware
SPEAKER_01of what's going on in order to care. Maybe they would if they knew, right? It's it's the fact that it's in the shadows that
SPEAKER_00I think uh look, a lot of the things that we're discussing here are um down to my favorite topic, the attention economy, right? Um the reality is that you have 24 hours a day, um, of which you know you're kind of continuously somehow gazing into a glass plate that is serving you up notifications. Uh some of those are algorithmically serving you up things that by definition are in rage bait, right? Because that's what gets a lot of engagement, right? And that gets amplified. And you are also a mammal that grew up on the steps and had to be tribal to survive. And that's also true about you. And therefore, a lot of these things, as you said, have always been like this, and they've just been dialed up to 100 now with this situation that we find ourselves in. So I don't think you'll get anybody to care about Sudan if they don't want to care about Sudan. Now you can say as much as you want about it, and maybe actually there's a chicken and egg situation. If everybody would put it on the front pages tomorrow, maybe somebody would start caring after two or three uh hours, uh, days, five days, six days. But I do think that we're certainly many people are certainly in these echo chambers now. And these echo chambers, which I call Overton mirrors, they've created this the side world in which they kind of occupy a media space that is uh edged on by people, and people are real. Reuters is not. Reuters is just you know, some sort of amorphous organization that can only do evil and in their mind. But like this person, Tommy Robinson, like he he's a real person, you know, good fella that I can relate to, and that also has a completely different quality, and all of a sudden you're competing with that. So attention is completely fractured, and I think it's very hard to get through all this noise now, whatever reporting you do. It I think we've created these really weird dynamics that just nobody can focus anymore. And then you have people, and this is the currency of our age, is flooding the zone, right? This is it's on the banner of this administration in the US. Has been from the beginning, since Steve Bannon was in the first administration, right? Flooding the zone because they know this, they know that this is the way you keep everybody distracted.
SPEAKER_02But
SPEAKER_01arguably you or your can your associates, contemporaries, um, colleagues are
SPEAKER_00finding the good funds.
SPEAKER_01Sure, but they're also aiding an Betting flooding because the more he does, the more the ability to
SPEAKER_00do it.
SPEAKER_01Focusing on
SPEAKER_00attention,
SPEAKER_01the more you focus on it, the more space it occupies, the less space there is for other things.
SPEAKER_02Now that's very difficult to define, right? But I always think about and which people. But I always think about, you know, lots of studies have been done on the bump that news organizations got during COVID. And the reason for that was that people's lives were on their line. And wherever they were,
SPEAKER_00their
SPEAKER_02lives were on the line. And so they needed trusted information on where to get their vaccines, which vaccines were better than others, um, or which vaccine their government was giving them, or how many people actually were dying, was their government telling them the right number, or not to drink Clorox, as somebody suggested at the time, you know, and things like that. And or even schooling, right? Like, you know, is my school up to speed on, you know, home learning and all of that. And it's interesting that when it came to sort of going to news organizations, including local ones, which had a spike, thankfully, in that time, then then people really kind of thought, hmm, let me go to the news that is actually verified when it really mattered to them, right? The problem with Sudan and you know the far-flung conflicts is that people, you know, don't it doesn't affect. And so part of the job that we have is to try to explain to people why is this important, right? But
SPEAKER_00arguably Gaza doesn't affect a lot of people, you know, either. But there's a lot of the
SPEAKER_02diaspora and that so I think that's why it's such a particular complex, because it's
SPEAKER_01well well, interestingly, we're funding both sides. We're we're giving Europe is giving Palestine a great deal of aid and support, and well, certainly since the crisis began, and at the same time also giving Israel a ton of support. And also Ukraine.
SPEAKER_02Well, and of military support, you know, of you know the US is I mean of military support, which now is being used in in Iran, by the way, but also in Ukraine. I mean, all of the money that's been given in Ukraine. So this actually matters, but it's really far away.
SPEAKER_01It's it's taxpayers' money. It's
SPEAKER_02taxpayers' money. And that's why it's important. So you have to um it somehow I think it's our job also to to explain to people, because this is the other problem. We speak from the height of our well, you should listen to me because I'm Reuters. But I mean, my own kids are like, What what? I mean, I I don't listen to you as my mother, and I don't listen to you as Reuters, right? You need to show me, prove to me that you are that I should, right? And that's true for news organizations, and that's why we've tried, you know, to to show our work, to sort of show people. I mean, BBC Verify is about that too, like showing people, like a journalist and how they actually um create being transparent about how they created that news. Like how did you, you know, who did you talk to? Who was this person? But obviously it it's you know, it's it's an open it's a sort of another.
SPEAKER_01And and to your point earlier on about resources and how much this stuff costs, I do think that people overlook that with this advent of Bellingcat and citizen journalism and so forth. Where are the resources? Okay, of course you can find out an awful lot in your basement on your computer. Once you're out in the field, you need legacy journalism, don't you? And you
SPEAKER_02see it, you know. I was once on this podcast where um with this famous podcaster, um, and he he said, Um, I'm an expert on Ukraine and I, you know, and I write about Ukraine and I and I said, Oh, I said, Oh, and do you have a team there? How many times? And he said, No. He said, No, um, you know, but I mean, I I read a lot. I've been once and I and I read a lot about what's out there and I consume a lot of news from Ukraine. And and this is someone who has many more followers on social media. I'm I'm chagrined to say, you know, than Reuters. And I was just flabbergassed and it was a perfectly nice person and uh and smart. But and I said, Oh, I was like, well, let me tell you how we cover Ukraine. We have 50 people on the ground, we're on the front lines, we're on both sides. By the way, we also have 40 people in Russia, because you can't cover a conflict until you unless you cover it on both sides. And that's something we believe we've done, you know, for for uh, you know, almost for 160 years. You know, we have covered conflicts from the both sides. We covered the American Civil War from both sides, right? Something we feel strongly about. And that's how we feel that we're bringing people, you know, the right information. But of course, when you look at the presence online, well, he has more all over. Well,
SPEAKER_01that's because he's tapping into belief systems. And and belief, again, it's ancient. That's where religion comes from. That's where, you know,
SPEAKER_02exactly
SPEAKER_01loyalty, affinity, which is whatever. You don't need to see those things, you just you feel it and you believe it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And going back to your point about the psychologists, was it you said who came in and sort of
SPEAKER_00I mean the the bottom line is I think some people are still tribal and some people are global. And I don't think it's easy to go from tribal to global. I I'm using global as a term here that is maybe not uh right, but uh I think it is hard to, as a as a monkey, to really understand and fully grasp the complexity of the world that we've created, the interconnectivity, the supply chains, the world and its interweaving economic flows and all this stuff that's going on. I mean, if you if you have so much going on in your life and you're like just trying to the min myriads of jobs that you're doing and like raising kids and all this other stuff, how much time do you really have to then actually look at all this stuff? And so at that point, when you're running on empty, what is the easiest thing to consume? It's something relatable, it's something tribal, it's something that makes you feel
SPEAKER_02good
SPEAKER_00doing the work, doing the both sides that requires calories to burn to actually think through both sides to do the research that you did after you spoke to your friend. Like that that was time that went into that. I think that's the problem that we're facing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And you need to care, obviously.
SPEAKER_01You need to care. And I and also I think um I think there's nothing more restful, in fact, than reaching understanding of something that is foggy and confusing. I think what's stressful is not understanding things and not and and being resistant and remaining ignorant. I'm very capable of being incredibly ignorant. I mean, you know, we discussed my schooling. I I elected to be ignorant about most things. Um it's much less stressful actually, defending one's ignorance than sort of asking a question and saying, Teach me. Of course, I didn't know that as a kid. But I mean, I I think we can all use the excuse about we're so busy and we're gonna
SPEAKER_00No, I just think the pursuit of truth and meaning is not as important to everyone. That's the bottom.
SPEAKER_02Except when it matters, and this is where I think there's something, and nobody has cracked this. And also you can only really crack this at a small level, like almost that's why I believe in local media so so much, right? Yeah, my
SPEAKER_01my dad, full disclosure, he's a journalist, but uh he he feels exactly the same way. The loss of local
SPEAKER_02media is tragic.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Because they make and also they hold you to account because that local news organization, if they say something that you as a resident in that town know to be untrue or know they haven't actually done their fully research and spoken to enough people, you can't get away with it. If we say something in Sudan, which is wrong, which we haven't, that's why, but if we said something, how could you, you know, how easy would that be to stress test? And that's the tragedy of of local news. But it does go back to, and and this is this is what we we have to strive, I think, to do two things. One, to explain to people why they should care, because otherwise they simply won't. And I'm a financial journalist, you know, I feel like I've been dealing with conflict now for the past five years, but I'm a financial, you know, I covered economics, business, financial conflict. Never went in a war zone except now as editor. And if you tell people, for example, that what is happening in Ukraine, what is happening in the Middle East, what is happening for the trade wars will have an effect on their ability to pay, to go to the supermarket, to pay their gas bill, uh, gasoline bill, their petrol bill, to do everything to buy from their purchasing power, it will make a difference on their mortgage. It will linking that, connecting the dots from something happening far away in the world, which is important, but why should I care? And then bringing it to why you should care because the world is interlinked. You know, go live somewhere on an island if you don't want the world to be interlinked and you want to be self-sufficient. That's the way. But that also, from the news organization's point, that
Reaching Young Audiences Without Losing Rigor
SPEAKER_02requires research and that requires explanation and patience. But that's the first thing. The second thing is format.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Because we cannot compete with these more creative, nibbial.
SPEAKER_00Dopamine. Dopamine, right? Right?
SPEAKER_02Like we've got to compete with them. We, well, I'm sorry, we can't be, oh, well, I've just written, and I love our investigations have changed the world, have changed policy, you know, at 3,000 words times six articles, you know, 20,000 words, right? They're brilliant. We've got to make them more visual. We've got to make them more like clickbaity. We've got to make them more, you know, vertical video. I mean, things like that. Got to do bullet points, you know, we've got to reduce very complicated facts into things that like can be done in a TikTok video. We have to do all of that. We can't pretend that we leave that because we're legacy media, so we're just gonna have fully packaged, beautiful, like, you know, hard.
SPEAKER_01With the with the TikTok format, for example, do you do that and then and then there's a link to the more substantive. Yeah. You see, I think that's great. Because I think then people can find out what they're interested in.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_01Um much more easily. So
SPEAKER_02do bytes. And then if you're interested, you can you can go deeper. Um and we do a ton on we do a ton on TikTok, we do a ton on YouTube. I mean, we uh do all of this. I mean, first of all, because our website is not has not traditionally been a destination because we haven't had one, right? And so we've had to go through um these other platforms, and they're working super well for us, you know. And the other thing is young people, right? I mean, I mean it's kind of an old trope, but it's true. We teach young people early to think that exercise is important and you know, have fruit instead of a dessert or whatever. Um I say this like loving dessert and baking cakes like every week, but anyway, um, and uh and maybe they'll have that in inside, right? And and but again, it has to be relevant to them. And that's the thing is the relevance. And then influencers, right? They're a reality. These influencers will say something, it'll be much more important than Reuters saying something. So we have to be open to maybe working with them, you know, having them understand that if they say something, maybe quote it, like source it. Like go try to tell people to go to the original source, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah,
SPEAKER_02encourage people, as I was saying before, apropos the person who didn't who didn't want to date you on the dating app. Well, fine. I I want people who will challenge me, right? And and that's I think that the
SPEAKER_00one thing that I would also probably advise everybody to consider is follow the money. I think that's really the the bottom line of all of this.
SPEAKER_01Well, not as a way to live life, but as a way to find out the truth of a conflict. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Not even the conflict. No, I'm talking about your sources.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00If you if an influencer is making money in a certain way, just understand where the money's coming from. Yep. Well, how they're there making money. Because now I quote my uh hero or one of my heroes, Charlie Munger, show me the incentives, I show you the outcomes. I read the FT is my uh poison of choice. And honestly, Japanese ownership, long thinking horizons and their business strategy and all that, they're very even Kielder Race Trafford. The economist. Okay. I know there's a leaning here, but like it feels very, you know, uh global-minded. Uh actually, the things with subscription, really. Bloomberg.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. Bloomberg's very trusted. You know, our mortal, you know, our I always say to John, who's the editor-in-chief of Bloomberg, you know, we're we're always the biggest competitors. We also like always go have lunch and gossip.
SPEAKER_00But
SPEAKER_02um and oh gosh, he once told me that Mike Bloomberg would not like me saying that. Sorry, Doug. Um and uh look at what's happened to the Washington Post, right? That's why people are so aghast at what's happening in the post, because it this was a moment where one of the world's richest men could actually I mean, every news organization has to be profitable, has to, you can't just bleed money, okay? We all agree with that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But you know, you also need to give it a chance. And it was seen as just bending to the administration, and that's why everybody was so aghast. And all the 300 people who have been who were great journalists who were fired, pretty much all most of them have been hired. We've hired a bunch as well. But yeah, you're absolutely right. Follow the money. Where is the conflict? You know, what what is the incentive, as you say, or what is the, you know, why is this specific? That's what we tell our journalists. Why is this person telling you this, right? Oh, I got this great scoop. Okay, that's great. We love scoops. But the person who told you what interest did they have in telling you that always the motivation is really, really important. Now, that doesn't mean it's not true. Sometimes people, I mean, people who are motivated because they think their company is doing something wrong or the wrong reasons, it doesn't matter. I
SPEAKER_00mean
SPEAKER_02but if the fact is the fact, right? You know, um, and that we wouldn't have, you know, people who are whistleblowers. I mean, their motivation is is is truth, but maybe also against their company might ruin the company and everybody might get fired. But so I mean, you know, but at least know it. So you know where you're, where they're coming from, right? But obviously, that's what we do as a profession. Everybody should be doing that, I think. Um
SPEAKER_00I agree. Let me ask you one more thing and um then we can start wrapping up. At the stage where AI
AI Hoaxes Retractions And Guardrails
SPEAKER_00is right now, I would have thought that we would have had like uh, I don't know, Prime Minister X is dead hoax that has gone viral, but like we don't because I mean right now you can actually manufacture things very believably, right, with the models that already exist that look very real. There seem to be some invisible guardrails here. Where are those? Are they at the platform companies? Is it that we call this stuff right away? I mean, I'm sure there's a bunch of stuff that's doesn't get to the surface that still manipulates people in some shape or form. But like we haven't had this really big event yet where something like that has gone viral. And I wonder where they've
SPEAKER_01stayed, you mean for over enough time. Or like
SPEAKER_00destabilized the market, or like has like all of a sudden a stock was shorted because of it, or something like that. We haven't had these big events yet, and I'm surprised by that. I I was wondering if you have thought about this or like anything.
SPEAKER_02I mean, we had one yesterday where we retracted a story because um it was regarded a sports story around the World Cup because some one of the team's coaches, I think, or heads of one of the teams had said something and it wasn't clear whether it was true or not, and we weren't able to verify it and it went out. You know, there was it was not quite clear. We we thought it looked real, but there was then there was some doubt over it, and so we retracted it. It was
SPEAKER_00like a video or audio? It was a video.
SPEAKER_02And and now, again, like these things are so can be so good. I mean, we had the famous example of Kensington Palace and and the the photo of Kate and the and the family, and that again, it was totally innocent, but it had been that it had been doctored, and so all of us had to retract it. So it happened, it some has happened, but yes, not a knock on wood, which I can't, otherwise I'll make a noise. Um, but some colossal thing has not yet happened. And I don't know why. I think there's still a lot of skepticism as to what this uh technology can do. And I think everybody is is is a little bit worried. Everybody in sort of the media ecosystem is is on edge. I know we're all on edge. We're I think consider this a good thing that while we are embracing the possibilities, a lot of us, at least in in many of the media organizations, I mean, including, by the way, social media are worried about the ramifications. So I think and then I wonder, and here I'm sort of, I don't know if you've had um Jimmy of Wi Jimmy Wells of Wikipedia on, but you know now obviously Wikipedia is different than than Reuters and then a news organization. But interestingly, um, he and I talk about this a lot. In Wikipedia, the the truth uh somehow after a bit of you know, the the the community surfaces the truth.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I completely agree. Right. And it's so lovely that it's not the lowest hanging fruit that it's actually yeah.
SPEAKER_02And that gives me such that gives me a lot of hope, right? Because it suggests that at the end of the day, society will balance itself, will provide some balance, maybe, you know, that uh it'll take a while. But I find that sort of very, very interesting. Maybe that's another reason that something comes and it's immediately debunked. You know, uh
SPEAKER_01Is that going back to your point about the money trail? Um so much of the integrity of Wikipedia must be the fact that it's volunteers. But they're just isn't that incentive. And so when the world operates in a different way than
SPEAKER_02it's a huge problem that so many of the world's media organizations are in the hands of of owners who do other things, like whose main business is other things, and therefore they have to be careful about crossing governments. It is a real problem. In the US, you have a lot of philanthropists who have financed media organizations. In Europe, it's much, much harder to do that. I mean, for tax laws and and laws on foundation setting up foundations and things of the sort. It would be great if if Europe, you know, UK, continental Europe had a system whereby it behooved philanthropists to back news organizations uh in the way that it has happened in the in the US.
SPEAKER_00Let me ask you uh maybe a little bit of a zoom out question uh to wrap.
No Shortcuts To Wisdom
SPEAKER_00If you think about our time right now, and you think maybe a hundred years ahead or something, what do you think is the smallest, hardest, most important fact that should survive all this?
SPEAKER_01In 2026, specifically
SPEAKER_02something
SPEAKER_00from
SPEAKER_02now that we should hold on to that needs to that we should at all costs like another.
SPEAKER_00Um, something along those lines. That we need
SPEAKER_02to protect almost. We need to push the.
SPEAKER_00Well, that would be.
SPEAKER_02That's very hard. I guess I I'll answer the question, but one of the things I'm worried about um as we introduce AI tools into our newsroom is that I worry that it's gonna be so easy to do all those things that schooled journalists like me and journalists before us, and this is true for journalism, but for every profession, right? That routine kind of sometimes drudgery that you had to do, but that taught you a lot, right? That that in a way gave you such a foundation to then build and and be like real critical thinkers. And you could sort of think critically and question because there were certain things that you knew how to do when you were schooled and how to you sort of had a foundation of of skill, if you will, right?
SPEAKER_01Oh also you've gone through certain pain thresholds to maybe gather that. And that you've gone through
SPEAKER_02pain, and so you appreciate it, right? I worry, and this is in journalism, but you know, for our kids, that it's all going to be so easy that
SPEAKER_00there are no shortcuts to wisdom. That there are no
SPEAKER_02shortcuts to wisdom and that we're creating more and more shortcuts. And look, I am sure that our parents and our grandparents said the same thing about television or about right, about the computer. So again, going back to your point where history repeats itself at the end of the day. But I I guess that when it becomes so easy, and then with AI, you know, when it reaches uh what's the holy grail?
SPEAKER_00Artificial uh general intelligence.
SPEAKER_02General intelligence, right? I mean, will people think anymore, right? And and so I guess that if something were to be preserved, if we can't preserve anything, is protect humanity, may critical thinking remain with humans, right? And if ever these robots or tools become too clever, shut them down, right? Like let the human remain clever and remain the thinker and remain and and and the debater and and the the in good and bad. I guess that's what I hope we can preserve. Like a little a little a little good debate, a little good conf controversy, and and not everything so easy. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So
SPEAKER_02I guess I think
SPEAKER_00that's a good point. I think that's
SPEAKER_01although superintelligence may help us to find some answers in the way that fail dismally and help us to align a little better than we're managing to do right now.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And also help us solve the some of the problems
SPEAKER_01we've created.
SPEAKER_00All
SPEAKER_02the problems we've created. So yes, yes, it's a real balance, but to keep something
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think dovetailing from what you're saying, I think what really for good or for bad that should be preserved is that there were people in this era that really did care about truth and to do the craft and hard work is required to uncover it, the facts to get to somewhere.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And and also I was recently at a very intimidating lunch with a number of Nobel Prize winners, and all of them without fail said that the thing, and maybe this is a trope too, but I think it's true, you know, without fail said that that, you know, it was they wouldn't have gotten where they were if they hadn't made so many mistakes and made, you know, failed so much. And then this perfect world where everything is you can reach sort of something right, the right answer so quickly. You know, allowing people to kind of muck around a little bit and flail a little bit.
SPEAKER_00Well, maybe we'll have a lot of time for that going forward.
SPEAKER_02Or maybe when the robots take over the road, we can just all go to the beach and muck around. I mean, I don't know.
SPEAKER_01This is another podcast.
SPEAKER_02Another podcast on a beach,
SPEAKER_00maybe. Yeah. Let's do this again on the beach. Um Alessandra, it's a pleasure to have you. Thanks for taking us on the global journey of facts.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_02Thank you.